
Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell meet Sherlock Holmes!
This book is a collection of short stories (and a novel) written by Randall Garrett. I read his Gandalara Cycle (which he wrote with Vicki Ann Heydron) as a teenager (which I have fond memories of, a sort of sword and sandals adventure series, about a man from the real world who wakes up another man’s body. And where the heroes are bonded to ridable, giant telepathic cats. Fun stuff, but that’s for another review.
What’s The Complete Lord Darcy about? They’re detective stories, set around the 1960s (although the timeline progresses into the future) in an alternate history. Technologically, it’s a bit like the Victorian era, where competent monarchies rule countries. Lord Darcy is an investigator for Duke Richard of Normandy, which is part of the Anglo-French Empire (and also includes ‘New England’ and ‘New France’).
Where’s the fantasy? Well, magic is real and follows several scientific principles. It’s not industrialised, but there are some hints of that happening in the edges of the stories. Sorcerers who work for the Catholic Church control magic. Darcy’s offsider is Master Sean, a registered sorcerer, who handles of Darcy’s crime scene forensics. The magic is based on the Hermetic magical tradition, such as the Law of Similarity, Sympathy and Contagion, which I recall from reading the Golden Bough years ago. Sean can do things like confirm that samples of blood taken from people are related. In one investigation, he turns a scrap of clothing is into a simulacrum of the original garment.
Magic isn’t used to directly commit crimes; there’s nothing like “the victim was killed by a magic missile upcast to the third level”. Instead, it’s all indirect. For example, foul play in one story was committed using the Law of Similarity, where a poor sap was brainwashed into thinking he was another individual, and things that affected the duplicate affected the actual victim.
Most of the mysteries are typical locked-roomed mysteries, where a member of the upper class is found dead in strange circumstances, and Darcy has to work out what’s going, occasionally making moral judgements on how he deals with the villains. Compared to Master Sean, Darcy is a bit bland as a character; a version of Sherlock Holmes without many of the quirks. But this is a feature, rather than a bug. In the space of a short story (and novel), Garret expertly introduces a mystery, magic system, alternate history and a usual cast of suspects and weaves a satisfying tale. Garret’s writing is clear, but dense, like chocolate mudcake. And he’s got a fondness for allusions and puns. One wizard at a conference, for example, is Grand Master Sir Lyon Gandophus. And some stories are riffs on existing mysteries, such as famous Agathar Christie books (such as Murder on the Orient Express). Because of the density of the stories, I had to reread them to see how they all fitted together.
My favorites in the collection involved a bit of international intrigue and skullduggery against the wicked, expansionist Polish Empire (who in this timeline control most of eastern Europe), which were A Case of Identity, and Ipswich Phial, which introduces a rival for Darcy, Special Agent Olga Polovski.
Having been fond of the Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell television series, which was largely a series of drawing room discussions, I was struck by how this book would be perfect for such an adaptation! You wouldn’t need a lot of special effects, just some Victorian-era outfits and drawing rooms.
World-building wise, I wondered how the empire remained stable for six hundred years, as it’s been around since the Plantagenet dynasty. Some stories mention the ongoing colonization of America; Lord John Quetzal, a relative of Montezuma, is from the duchy of Mexico, and is a prominent character Too Many Magicians . Asia isn’t referred to, but one could assume they are still ruled by their competent monarchies, much as Europe is. (Where perhaps, Judge Dee analogs are involved in their own intrigue.) And perhaps Australia hasn’t even been discovered yet.
I highly recommended this collection, but I recommended reading one story at a time and savouring it rather than trying to devour it all at once.